1st ed Beedrill PSA 9

Background:
One sold recently on auction for $152 and another is listed for $150 right now. Other PSA 9 rares tend to go for about $50 (dragonair for a bit higher). Beedrill seems to be a bit more scarce, doesn’t pop up as often on ebay. PSA reports a pop of 84 for Beedrill, other rares have at least a pop of 120.

Value:
I understand why the Beedrill went for more (see: scarcity) but I’m wondering if $150 is a bit high. Should I be patient on this one? I feel like the dry spell is temporary and if there is a time where 2 or 3 are listed at the same time, you won’t see it go for as much.

Scarcity:
This question might be more interesting. Why is this card relatively hard to find? Were less copies printed? Or something else??

Idk if it helps, but I sold a bare minimum near mint copy , maybe on the excellent side last week for $50.

It was only listed for about a week before it sold.

2 Likes

The situation in which I caution people is when a card has a lower population report at a certain point and the price for the card balloons, but then the population of the card catches up to the other cards in the set while the price retains its premium due to the inertia of the market. In situations like that, I urge people to use caution and wait for a market correction.

In the case of Beedrill, this seems like a card where the population is *significantly* below its counterparts.

Beedrill - 84
Dragonair - 167
Dugtrio - 132
Electabuzz - 134
Electrode - 128
Pidgeotto - 140

My best assessment is that you can expect to pay a significant premium for the Beedrill for a long time to come.

@namespace url(XHTML namespace);

3 Likes

Agreed. I remember not long ago a couple members wanted a price for the full non holo PSA 9 set and that beedrill price caught my attention. That pop number makes a lot of sense now.

I don’t think it will get any cheaper. Unless you find a raw copy which some e4 members might hook you up with.

Could playability have something to do with it? I’ll tell you…they have always been scarcer. Mint copy’s just didn’t show up very often.

@garyis2000 No way playability has anything to do with it. In the original era of the Pokemon TCG Beedrill was scarcely used, while Electabuzz was one of the most overpowered and overused monsters. I have to assume there’s something about its placement on the printing sheet that caused more defects during manufacturing.

Interesting.

I checked a couple of my foreign base Rare sheets and the rare pokes and trainers have a pretty equal mix.
I’d like the numbers on a 1st Rare sheet.

So basically this Beedrill will sting my wallet and no one really knows why. Great :blush: lol

I would put the value of these now at close to 100.00

1 Like

Moral of the story: patience pays off.

m.ebay.com/itm/Pokemon-Beedrill-1st-edition-base-PSA-9-/172912826629

3 Likes

That’s about right. Having only 7 per sheet it’s over 15% rarer?