Craziest offer you’ve gotten for a card?

Those who were big sellers during 2020-2021. What was the wildest offer you got on a card that had you speechless?

“What’s your lowest?”

43 Likes

When PSA 9 Base Unlimited Charizard were selling for like $7,000 and I had purchased two of them in 2018 for $200 each. But then I didn’t sell them. Why didn’t I sell them…

14 Likes

What grade were they?

This is probably going to be the best answer

I got offered this stack of gold stars including rayquaza and zard for my set of 9 topps johto series 1 holograms, felt quite crazy but didn’t want to part with them

8 Likes

What is the history of your topps hologram set?

1 Like

It’s just a very scarce set of chase cards, the set was short printed and there were only one hologram per box. Also they were sold in US only while earlier topps releases were sold world wide. Unlike topps chrome cards that are sturdier these are like all other earlier topps releases that get damaged more easily with their sharp corners so odds of them making it to this day are lower than with chrome cards. Also the holo pattern is just beautiful so they are overall very iconic cards amongst topps collectors

16 Likes

57 Likes

That reverse holo metapod from 151 just keeps getting rarer and rarer.

26 Likes

PSA 9

That’s a huge offer

This was from last year, but a $3000 offer for my PSA 10 Dream League Clefairy Lillie promo. I accepted. Now looking to rebuy it for under $300. That was just insane. It ended up being the highest price one sold for on eBay I think.

13 Likes

Ill bring it back down to earth for a second i recently was offered 150 USD for my staff pichu and thats probably the most anyones offered me out of the blue for one of my cards. I can’t part with him. I paid $18 US for it and it was a whole pure luck thing.

7 Likes

January 2021

12 Likes

Last year I had an offer of 10k CAD that got auto declined for my PSA 9 Alola Friends (Setting on best offers).
I would have definitely accepted if it went through.
I later sold it on auction for 6k CAD.
The same card is worth 1.8k CAD today.

5 Likes

what card was that for?

During ~10 years I haven’t sold stuff too often yet on old forum I was approached many times especially about some booster boxes, however one of the most memorable offers was $30k for PSA 10 1st ed. Neo Genesis Slowking 14/111.

Surely there’s lots of stuff I could’ve obtained after sale but ended up holding the card, doesn’t make any sense to break set which is (still) missing one card. :slight_smile:

1 Like

I am guessing the SNAP Bulbasaur? I know @thundermoo has a copy!

Cheers!

4 Likes

A romantic date night with Smpratte in Milan for only 1.95 million seems like a steal!

10 Likes