Blastoise, NM, ungraded. What would be a fair price?
This one to be exact, is that a good price?
Hey buddy I bought one for quite a bit more so that one looks like a good price. With these cards, psa and bgs won’t grade them. Psa encapsulates them in their custom green case.
Having said that there has been 2 blastoise for sale for over a month now. One says it’s in possible gem mint condition so maybe go for that one if you’re worried about quality. Otherwise just make an offer on both and see which one gives you the better deal 
and when you’re done you can pick up the FPO manhole card for $50 000 haha
Edit: I’ve just looked at the card closely. Def not psa 10 condition like they state. Looks like there’s whitening around the edges. The other ones photos aren’t very good either. See if you can get some close ups?