What is this worth in this condition?
I don’t know why that has become known as the cigar error, this is the original “cigar error” I think the Charizard Authority originally got it from his WOTC sources:
The two are completely unrelated errors. I think @ocghp got them a bit confused 
1 Like
I’ve never even seen that one before.
I don’t know if that guys price was high or not, but I got that cigar error for 150 and a psa 10 misty’s tears for 35. He’s got another weird error card for sale with Alakazam and it looks like it was printed twice once other the other. I am not sure what it is though.
Yeah that’s the actual Cigar error. To differentiate people usually put “Cigar” error, as you see with some of the other ones for sale on eBay. @masonkampe
Yes those are both fair prices… especially the misty’s tears. The Alakazam isn’t double printed it just has poor registration. One or more colors are misaligned.
2 Likes
The Cigar Hitmonlee was my card, not charizard authority. Yes, I sold it for I think 3000.00 a year or two ago.
An interesting note. I named it that because I thought it was a cigar band. Later I realized it wasn’t a cigar band (thanks to my Hawaiian brother Keliiahonui). It was part of the company’s logo at the end of the holofoil roll. But for years cigar hitmonlee was used and the name continued to stick;)
7 Likes
If you would have been a member of Pokegym sooner you would have know when you first listed it.
pokegym.net/forums/archive/index.php/t-173051.html 
I thought I joined the gym well before that? Plus, I believe that was the third time I listed it? I think I left the gym by that time because pokepop was really unprofessional towards me which is why I never saw this.
My memory is fuzzy after this amount of time.
1 Like
I have always called this stained hitmonlee
1 Like