How should classic booster boxes fundamentally be valued?

Wondering if anyone has insights into the pricing dynamics between sealed mint booster boxes and the packs inside. For example, should a sealed box be valued at a premium or discount to what the individual packs would sell at if all 36 were sold? I assume it’s a premium but how much do you think is reasonable? Or should they be roughly equivalent in price?

What you have to understand is that a sealed box is a collectible item in and of itself just as loose packs are collectible items.

For that reason, the sealed box should be worth more.

The hierarchy generally goes:

  • sealed boxes
  • sealed packs
  • cards inside the packs (talking ungraded)

Obviously, there are some notable exceptions (e.g. 1st Edition Base Set Charizard), but that is the general rule.

1 Like

the meta right now is to break boxes and sell the single packs as unweighed or heavy/light, some people make quite a profit by doing so, especially if they buy discounted boxes that are not in Mint condition.
Personally I would always pay a premium for a booster box over 36 loose packs, but the reality is that very few people have several thousands of dollars to spend on a box, that’s why they opt in booster packs even at the risk of them being weighed.

2 Likes

Maybe insert these category’s?

  • sealed boxes
  • sealed unweighed packs
  • card’s inside the packs (graded)
  • sealed weighed packs
  • cards inside the packs (talking ungraded)

Only reason I didn’t include graded is because I was only talking about what’s actually inside the box.

Just to expand on this and shift a few of the orders

Sealed boxes
Chase cards (graded 8+)
Sealed heavy packs
Sealed unweighed packs
Chase cards (ungraded NM, expected to grade < 8)
Sealed light packs
Non-chase cards (graded 8+)
Non-chase cards (ungraded NM, expected to grade < 8)

3 Likes

What did I start lol.

I think its a great exercise to do - gives a general idea as to what people value/what items will most likely retain value, among other insights.

  1. Pallet of sealed cases of sealed booster boxes
  2. Sealed case of sealed booster boxes
  3. Sealed booster box
  4. Sealed booster pack
  5. Raw cards from pack
1 Like