Since the damage is done, I’ll leave this poll here, and my own answer under spoiler:
Is collecting fakes for pussies?
Summary
Yes.
I’d like to revive and enlarge the topic and talk about it, cause there are different types of fake and different motivation for buying them.
Personally, it’s most a matter of economical advantage and availability of the product.
Also, it gets you the ethical dilemma. Is it right to buy them? Is it right to sell them?
I have to make some examples:
Pikachu Trophy? SSB Trophy? the Illustrator?
Will I ever be able to afford them? No.
I want them in my collection? Yes.
It’s “gotta catch 'em all!” baby, why shouldn’t I want them.
Are these fakes good ones? No. They are a fist in the eye. But a good eye can be punched even from better proxies, so what’s the point of getting a 50$ fake instead of a 3$ fake that’s not even made out from cardbord, it’s just plastic?
As a binder collector, looking at the empty slots in my collection makes empty myself.
I just can’t stand the fact I can’t have something like a piece of cardboard.
When I was a kid my family wasn’t a rich one, so getting pokemon cards was a moment of joy, and the fact that I couldn’t just catch them all made me sad.
Growing up and getting my own job gave me back courage and a new strenght for collecting, but I’ve come to a wall I can’t climb. To me it’s ok to buy a fake in this case so that I can have a palliative, until it stays in my collection and never gets out of it.
It’s like cheating in your save file a celebi, after completing RSE and FRLG multiple times to fill the pokedex. Damn, after clearing emerald regional dex 3 times to get the johto starters you can’t keep me away from filling it whole.
Jumbo not-jumbo.
As above but maybe worse?
Jumbo cards can’t fit in a binder. The originals sure are affordable, but what’s the point of buying them as a binder collector, if I can’t fit them into my binder?
So this guy made some good quality proxies in the standard size of regular cards so that I can enjoy these artworks alongside my other cards.
Also, this guy is from Italy too, so I’m more than glad to spam him here so he can get noticed (hopefully).
I absolutely want those fake phone cards from seven years ago if it matters
Unique fakes.
Haven’t you ever desired to own mewthree? Venustoise? Or the ghost from lavender town?
That guy from above has made even those cards available, in an art style that reminds of Sugimori-sensei (all heil to Sugimori-sensei!).
What I’m trying to say here is that fake cards can make possible something that to nowadays is not, and probably never will otherwise. And I think it’s beautiful.
Just cool stuff.
Someone (me) can argue that some cards are just cool. I like these cards that tries to replicate the ancient mew style, with the unown fonts instead of runic, and some nice holo (not everyone, ok, some just scream “faaaaake” from the distance and it’s not objectively good to see but still) I’m trying to get all the legendaries from gen1 to gen4 in this style.
Now that I’ve made this post I can never again be a trve collector.
Cause trve collectors don’t buy fakes.