The 1999 Tropical Mega Battle Bilingual Exeggutor

A Guide To: The 1999 Tropical Mega Battle Bilingual Exeggutor

By: Raichuforyou
image

Introduction

A bit of an enigma in the Pokemon card collecting scene, the bilingual Exeggutor given out at the 1999 Tropical Mega Battle (TMB) is one of the most elusive cards ever released by Media Factory. I recently came into possession of one and because this card is so overlooked, I wanted to detail a few things about it for the community. I had a hard time finding information about it and most of the info I did find was from a long time ago.

Oftentimes the threads and sources I found were based merely on speculation or hearsay. Therefore, in this guide I want to discuss the circumstances of this card’s release, how to identify the TMB version, and provide a side by side comparison of the TMB version and the Trainer’s Magazine Volume 3 version. Most of this is not new or groundbreaking but it is a compilation of the facts about this extremely rare promo from the heyday of Pokemon.

The Road To Hawaii: Distribution

So what was the Tropical Mega Battle and how did players earn the original bilingual Exeggutor? The Tropical Mega Battle was a series of 9 regional events in Japan during the summer of 1999. These events were intended for younger players (ages 11-14) to battle it out for a chance to play in the finals. The finals were to be held in Hawaii (August 24-27) at the Hilton Hawaiian Village. Players from the all over the world would come together for one exclusive tournament. In the USA, the top 12 ranking players in the DCI point system (the American ranking system) got an invite to Hawaii. Japanese players earned an invite by qualifying at one of the regional events.

Speculation Time: Attendence

Because each of the 9 Japanese regional tournaments yielded 3 trophy cards, it would make sense that 1st, 2nd, and 3rd place players at each event received an invite to the TMB finals. That would mean 27 Japanese players got an invite to Hawaii. Based on reported attendance, not all of the Japanese players were able to attend.


No.2 TMB Trophy Card

The most reliable estimations place attendance of the 1999 Tropical Mega Battle finals between 36 and 50 players. We do know that a year later in the 2000 finals there were 42 players. The number 42 was officially disclosed by Wizards of The Coast in an online Q&A chat session. So it’s probably safe to assume the 1999 finals had a similar number of

The bilingual Exeggutor was given to each participant of the Hawaii finals at the award ceremony on the last day of the event. Because so few were legitimately distributed it is important to collectors to know exactly how many are out there. Pinpointing an exact number would be exciting, however, it may not be possible due to translation issues, lack of internet and overall bad documentation at the time, and loss of records when the game transferred from WOTC to the Pokemon Company. At best we can say less than 50 copies of this card were distributed.

Speculation Time: Copies

Another number that came up in my research was 36. Due to the scarcity of this card I would not be surprised if distribution was this low. Because the TMB in 2000 had about 42 participants I would assume the first event in 1999 had slightly fewer.

image
Image from 2000 Tropical Mega Battle

In summary the distribution of this card was extremely limited. Only the best players in their division could earn the invite and even fewer could make the journey to Hawaii that August. Given the amount of time that has past since the event took place it is likely that a few have been lost. Some of those young players may not have realized that this would become such a sought after collectible. Today even finding images of the card is difficult and those that exist are few.

Multiple Personalities

If you are familiar with early Japanese promos you know that many of them received reprints for alternate forms of distribution. I believe this is because they knew how difficult it was to obtain some of them in the first place. So, in true Media Factory fashion, the bilingual Exeggutor was reprinted and released as an insert in Trainer’s Magazine Volume 3 later that year in October. This version featured a glossy finish which seems to be the biggest difference between the two releases. The TMB version was printed without this glossy finish. This is most visible in the middle image below.



Surface image provided by @hersheycardcollector TMB version left; Trainer Magazine version right

HD Images provided by @linkdu83 . Trainer Mag Version on the left; TMB Version on the right

The other major difference between the TMB version and the Trainer’s Magazine Vol.3 version is the level of saturation in the colors. While the Vol.3 version features deeply saturated colors, the TMB version looks washed out and faded. Where the Vol.3 version may have dark grey in certain places the TMB version will have a lighter grey (almost white sometimes). The same is true of the brown, tan, and green colors in the card. The color difference is also evident in the Energy symbols and set symbol. Overall the TMB version looks a bit lighter than your average Japanese card from that era. The top and bottom images above illustrate the difference in colors and

One other key difference to note is the text. The text on the TMB version appears more faint and looks almost as if it were written with pencil. The Trainer Mag version has a more saturated black text. This is most apparent in the text at the very bottom border of the card.

Exeggutor Used Confusion!

Older forum posts on E4 (at the time UPCCC) show that the TMB version remained a total mystery in collecting circles until over a dozen years after its initial release. Speculation had been tossed around about how the two versions differed and what if anything made the TMB version unique. Many people had come to believe that the TMB version had different text on the bottom border. An image from one of the Japanese CDs was cited as evidence of this:

It made sense that the TMB version would not contain the phrase “Trainer’s Magazine Vol. 3”. Some speculated that it should contain a phrase referencing the TMB or Hawaii.

Eventually that was proven to be false as a competitor from the 1999 TMB chimed in on the conversation. Username djcantu2 was able to clarify once and for all:


Medal distributed in 2000 Tropical Mega Battle

References & Resources

Chat Logs Containing TMB References:


Image from Trainer’s Magazine Vol. 3 provided by @linkdu83

Source Material

1999 Player Report
Pokemon Card Resource (PCR)
Thread “Tropical mega battle 1999-2001” Feb 17, 2012
Thread “1999 Tropical Mega Battle. Some Things I Found” Aug 15, 2012
Thread “Early Tournament Participation Cards” Mar 23, 2012
Thread “Some Early Japanese Pokemon Trophy Card Research” Jan 26, 2014
Thread “WotC Chat Logs from Feb 2000 to Nov 2000 - Q&A w/ Employees” Jun 26, 2017

Thanks to @hapycakeoven @scratchdesk @djcantu2 @linkdu83 @hersheycardcollector and @cbd1235 for their contributions to the community. They’re research greatly aided me in writing this article.

37 Likes

Thanks for reading! Any comments or suggested edits are welcome. I’ll make edits as necessary.
After getting a Tropical Mega Battle Bilingual Exeggutor last year I had trouble verifying that it was indeed the TMB version. I did conclusively verify that it was later on. This guide is intended to help identify the TMB version from its Trainer Mag counterpart and provide background information on the card. Enjoy!

Very well written!

1 Like

Nice guide. Well done.

1 Like

Great job :blush:

1 Like

Great guide! I always love reading about the TMB and other first-generation tournaments.

As the owner of one of the TMB trophy cards, I’m curious as to whether anyone on the E4 has compiled a list (partial or complete) of with who and/or where all of the original-era trophy cards (PIkas, TMBs and SSBs) have ended up. Are all of the cards accounted for? Have some been lost to history or the trash heap?

1 Like

I think a long time ago we started a thread on here trying to put a list together with current owners but for some reason it stopped

I know for a fact that many copies are still in the hands of the winners :blush:

I think it was @pokemontrader who started the thread tracking the trophies. He must not have had time to keep it going. Either way interesting to know that some remain with their rightful winners!

@japanime thanks for checking it out! I’ve found myself pretty interested in the early events lately. It’s amazing that some of this stuff happened over 20 years ago already!

2 Likes

I tried but then the guide fizzled out.

A lot of the trophy cards are with private collectors. Back in the day it was easier to catalog everything, but they are so spread out today and more private.

Great guide and well written :blush:

1 Like

Hey guys! Just added some images provided to me by @linkdu83
He scanned both versions of the card in HD quality. This shows us the two cards side by side in greater detail.
He was also nice enough to scan the article in Trainer’s Magazine Vol. 3 for me to add.
Thanks for that Henri!

7 Likes

The PSA 10 pop report on these is off by at least one.

2 Likes

I want to say even two. I believe I’ve seen two mislabeled copies in my lifetime

1 Like

Guys, can I determine if this is mislabelled even thought I already have it in a slab?

Storeytime: the provenance. I was 8-10 years old and playing in the pokemon battle league at Mitsuwa marketplace in Arlington Heights, IL. I acquired this card through a trade with an older (probably 20s-30s) Japanese guy who specifically said he played tournaments in Japan and this was a card “you could not get in the USA”. Apart from that, the details are fuzzy - with my Dad as the (not-so) impartial judge and broker who would not sign off on a trade for any of my Charizards that this gentlemen wanted, we came to deal for multiple other holos for this card from what I remember. Which specifically, I couldn’t say - but my deep, fuzzy memories say it was something like a lesser Zard or Blastoise and a Clefable and maybe something else; 2 or 3 holos for one non-holo.

Sidenote, the same guy basically freaked out when he saw I wasn’t sleeving before putting my cards in the binder and taught my dad and I a very valuable lesson in ‘The Way’ of Pokemon collecting, he was clearly ahead of the times as this was circa 1999-2000 and I had been buying Japanese boosters since 96’-97’ before it hit the American market but had no idea of how the storage effected future value as has proven very true.

Anyhow, got it graded a few years ago after digging into it - many thanks to this thread - and now want to come full circle and see if it can be e4 authenticated.

Thank you all in advance for the joy and passsion we all share in these old scraps of paper :smiley:

6 Likes

That looks like the trainers magazine version. The top right corner curl is very common in glossy cards. Nonetheless your story you shared is cool!

4 Likes

dat one dont look right :face_with_monocle: crazy gotta watch out for these

3 Likes

Yeah, tie isn’t long enough, it’s not the TMB

7 Likes

I was waiting for this to be shared! I had the pics cropped and everything but wasn’t sure how many knew about the tie!

TMB version

Trainers mag (op’s card)

7 Likes

:pleading_face: thank you Scott and friends for confirmation of my worst fears. I was duped! Damn, and such a great story for someone that was scammed. Thank god my dad didnt let that guy get any of my good zards
 i got another story about that but right now im too busy cleaning up my tears: i own a mislabel, thank you one guy grading pokemon at PSA

Thank you all sincerely, the truth hurts but it feels better than living a lie

Pete

6 Likes