… a psa10 shining gyarados 1st edition… psa10 blaine’s charizard 1st and blaine’s arcanine 1st
if those two offers were the same price.
very tough but I would pick Shining Gyarados haha
1 Like
Personally, the Charizard/Arcanune, thought Gyarados seems to be far and few with new listings.
1 Like
I would go for Gyarados since there are less than a 100 psa 10s in the market.
But it is a tough one, Charizard will always carry weight but maybe easier to come by in the future since there is over 250 psa 10 cards currently.
1 Like
Also I maybe biased as I’m chasing to complete my neo shining collection…
2 Likes
That’s indeed a tough one. Maybe flip a coin, haha? 
I personally would go with the Gyarados probably. I love that artwork, and it recently started to clime in price from what I’ve seen for all different variations (1st or unlimited, graded or raw).
But you can also never go wrong with a Charizard, and the Arcanine is an added bonus.
So indeed a tough decision. I’d say go with the option you like the most.
Greetz,
Quuador
1 Like
arcanine is around pop 120 aswell… i traded it, that’s why i ask, maybe i can give him something else if he accepts, cards are still here haha. i love all 3 cards…
1 Like
I’d probably go with the Shining Gyarados, it’s a more iconic card of the hobby IMO and the artwork stands out (although all 3 cards you mentioned have great artwork).
I love both Neo Revelations Shinings (Gyarados and Magikarp) even though I’m not that taken by the Shinings in Neo Destiny.
5 Likes
Couldn’t agree with this more. I’ve always felt that the Neo Destiny Shinings were actually kind of boring. I love the Raichu, but that’s it.
The Neo Revelation Shinings are far superior, in my opinion. Wish WOTC would have stuck with that formula in Destiny.
3 Likes
As hyped up as Shining Charizard is, that specific artwork just doesn’t do it for me and really leaves something to be desired. It’s just flying away with a big booty pic. Both the Revelation Shinings have better artwork IMO.
3 Likes
Yeah, Charizard must have fallen on hard times. Was definitely going for those Instagram likes.
1 Like
My favorite is the Shining Tyranitar card and second is the Shining Magikarp.
Noctowl isn’t a bad shout for a good looking card either.
I already have the gyarados, i dont have the other 2. If i had the chance to literally trade the gyarados for both arcanine and charizard i wouldnt.
If i happen to have the money to buy either one of the other i’d go for the gyarados.
Blaine’s Arcanine current price wont stay there… my 2 cents.
2 Likes
By won’t stay there, do you mean it will rise or go down?
1 Like
On the playground you’d get laughed outta recess if you traded the Charizard and Arcanine for the Gyarados. I’ll stick with that logic.
Charizard and Arcanine.
Blaines zard 1st ed psa 10 just sold for 3.5k this morning. Blaines arcanine is worth about 1.5k
I’m not 100% sure what the shining gyarados will sell for but even if it breaks the 3k mark next auction, it still won’t be worth as much as the other two. Not combined anyway.
I think if one were to trade the shining gyarados for the blaines zard, that would be a fair trade in my opinion. Yes there are less shining gyarados’ but the demand for the blaines zard has driven the price up over 4x the past 4 months and it’s showing no signs of stopping
I’d rather say the charizard will drop, more likely than the arcanine. yes, it’s charizard, but double pop. both are kinda low pop for english sought after cards.
well the current prices are ridiculous. as the psa10 ray goldstar sold yesterday for 23k, 2 months ago sold for 8k.
i wonder what the gyarados would sell in those times… also hard to say as there is no one on ebay at the moment, so we can’t compare those two ebay prices right now. that’s why i was asking for opinions here 
Ray didnt sell, it was shilled. My friend owns the card.
1 Like