WTT For a BGS 9.5 1st ed Zard

I have posted wanting to trade for this card before, but am adding quite a bit more here to see what I drum up.

Wanting BGS 9.5 1st ed Charizard.
Value 6k-15k depending on subs.

Offering
-BGS 9.5 Shadowless Charizard Subs 9.5 except centring is 9 (the card is pack fresh. Value??? I’ve had an offer of 4k. So 4-5k?

-BGS 9.5 Shadowless Blastoise Quad 9.5 value $2-3k? (Incredibly clean)

-BGS 9.5 Shadowless Venusaur Quad 9.5 value $800-1k (consecutive cert to blastoise and also very clean)

-BGS 9.5 Shadowless Chansey Subs 9.5 except centering 9 $800-1k??

-BGS 9.5 Shadowless Poliwrath Subs 9.5 except surface (have no idea why surface isn’t higher) 250-300

COMPLETE PSA 10 Shadowless non holo Base set 17-102 (both pika) ~4k

Also these PSA 9 SHADOWLESS HOLOS That I have spent the last year cherry picking to cross to BGS but haven’t yet.

Alakazam
Clefairy
Gyarados x2
Machamp
Nidoking
Magneton
Hitmonchan
Mewtwo
Ninetales

I’ll value them all at $100 to be as fair as I can.
So that’s another $1000

In total, valuing everything I have safely I’m over 12k trade value.
If the stars aligned maybe 15k?

I am located in Canada but have a US mailing address, And am prepared to use any middle man or however you want to do this.

Just FYI, you value your quad BGS shadowless about 80-90% of a PSA 10 price, so it would seem you would want need to value a Quad BGS 9.5 charizard at about 80-90% of a PSA 10, which would not be below 30k. So that BGS 9.5 charizard is about 24-27k. Just was based on your logic. Plus, you are offering additional low end cards, so you would need to offer something pretty crazy. Don’t be disappointed by the poor response. Plus, BGS 9.5 is not common for a Charizard.

I’d say be patient and maybe grad one from a future PWCC auction for way cheap. That’s probably easier and cheaper.

Or if you can reach out to PWCC and ask who won those past BGS 9.5 charizard and see if you give those buyers a solid offer, since several only sold for 6-8k. If you double the price of what they paid, they might be willing to let go for quick profit.

People are starting to see the mistakes PSA is making. You see that shadowless 10 zard right now at 10k with 24 hours left? It’s disgusting. It’s like PSA says “holo looks good, centering is good. Who gives a shit about the back of the card” I’ve seen the same with stoise and venusaur. I try to buy the card and not the grade. That had slowly led me BGS. If anybody wanted to compare their 10 with my 9.5. I’d love to do so. I can send as many photos as needed of every part of either card. I’m tired of people making 1000’s off of PSA’s mistakes. I think others are too. Regardless I do think you are right about my best chance being some sort of auction. I’m also raising funds fairly quickly. But damn man! We talk on messages. You just can’t help yourself to chime in on here :joy:. I guess everybody wants to protect the value of a card they own when it goes for half the price of what they think it’s worth at auction! Seriously though. I do appreciate the response!

I agree, that shadowless charizard is a joke.

Haha, hey man, it’s a public forum and my goal is to help people connect the dots. I am a big BGS fan for sure. I’m totally on your side.

I just realized BGS is in Dallas, which is where I am from. I need to get some cards graded down the road.

1 Like