Squirtle was the very first starter I chose when I first played Pokemon Red. I remember leveling it to lv92 before starting the game all over again. Final four did not stand a chance
My very first holo rare pull was the Nidoking from unlimited base set. I still have the card today, not in the best condition though lol
I always thought missing no was a cool bug. On one of my last play throughs of Pokemon Red, I collected all the pokemon including missing no, but no Mew.
If I had to extend the list a little bit, I think that Greninja would be a solid addition. Its probably the only starter post gen 4 thats held any sort of longevity in popularity. Just a really, really cool design and a pokemon thats popular in multiple areas of Pokemon (tcg, video games, tv show, merch) More popular than gen 2 starters imo.
I think Mew is another good one. Not as popular as Mewtwo, but definitely a top 10.
Sorry guys but you’re trolling if you don’t put Pikachu in the top 3 iconic Pokemon… Pikachu might be a top 3 iconic character in all media at this point
Lugia (this was the first legenary pokemon that i thought “Woooowww” especially after seeing Pokemon 2000, it was so cool like some whale-dinosaur-plane)
Mew (i think mew is an Entity at this point and it will be forever around)
When I mentioned Rayquaza I also loved it’s ex cards and thought they were the chase cards when I was younger , yet little did I know back then there was his gold star version lol I had know idea he had a GS until I was in my early 20’s
Next would be a tossup between Mewtwo and the other two Gen 1 starters but I think those ones cannibalize each other on the list putting Lugia ahead of them.